Your aversion to '2nd guessing' is curious, Wanny, given that 2nd guessing is an integral part of what a coach must face in first rank college sports.
We have 9 guys playing double digit minutes on average. I think there's a consensus that we are athletic (if not skilled as far as basketball and offense go). So, it would seem to me that we have a club which should apply full court and 3/4 court pressure fairly often. Do we do that at all? If so, how much?
Funny you say this Monroe, because I was asking this question to my companions on the way back to Columbus Sunday night after the RMU game. Seems to me that we have a roster capable of more 3/4 court and 1/2 court pressure/trapping defense that we've seen in the past.
Now...If I were distributing minutes...I don't think I can say specifically how many minutes any one player should be playing, but this is what my rotation would look like.
Starting 5 depending on the size and/or approach of the opponent:
1 - DJ - I'm not sure he isn't capable of 40 mins a game half the time. Clearly, we go as he goes.
2- Kellogg - clearly needs to play more minutes than he has so far IMO
3- Freeman/Hall - TJ can't be taking that many jump shots if he is going to play starters minutes
4- Baltic - I think, our most consistent post player, not our best.
5- Washington - the guy we need to get more from the most. I think we need 15pts, 10 boards a game from him to succeed.
Bench:
1st off: Freeman/Hall - whoever doesn't start. Instant offense theory says to me Tommy should be the 6th man.
2nd: Sayles - can play the 3,4,5 in MAC games, and can handle the ball reasonably well.
3rd: Johnson - and when he's in, I feel like we should be trapping/pressing more to use his quickness. Also, why not have him on the floor on occasion with DJ, Nick, and Tommy, and go small to create matchup problems sometimes?
4th: Keeley - I'd give him 17-19 mins a game, mostly to keep Devo out of foul trouble. He needs to play stronger and play as big as he is.
This highlights the need, desperately, to have found a way to keep another player from Coleman, Kinney, AB, or Horne on the roster. That, and the Alex Kellogg hole is noticeable when foul trouble creeps in.