If they have to pay a specific fee to participate in a sport, should parents -- and maybe students -- have a more direct say in the how the team is run?
.
Good thought and one more way the education system is failing kids.
I think if that becomes the norm you will see sports become more club oriented and less local HS.
It's already happening in Ohio, particularly with basketball, volleyball, softball and baseball. It has almost always been that way for soccer and lacrosse (which is not yet an official OHSAA sport).
I don't think a move toward club/private sports will have a significant impact on players at the highest level in terms of future athletic opportunities-- colleges will find them. But, it could have a negative impact on them in other ways. And, in my opinion, there could be significant impact on kids who aren't elite athletes, their schools' teams and the school/broader community.
This is a rich topic and would make a great discussion over dinner sometime.