You are one tough grader, Sir!
I would tend to grade on my expectations (realistic) vs. how they performed up to those expectations.
Jaylin gets an "A" because I expected him to be our starting point guard out the gate, be a leader on the court and score the ball. He did all those things.
Baker gets a "C" because I hoped that he would score a ton for us, be a leader on the court and join with Hunter to rival Jacobs and Carry from Kent. Instead he was a solid bench guy with occasional nice games. If anything, he was a very nice teammate who didn't seem to whine or worry about PT. But...he also took minutes away from EJ4 and AJB that they both needed.
Wiz gets a "C" from me because, unlike many of you, I had the expectation of him giving us 10 minutes per game to spell Dwight, score a little bit and grab some boards. He gets a "C" because of his horrible tendency to move on screens and his lack of court awareness at times. But as a project big man with three years left for us, he was certainly not a failure.