The issue I have is that, as a fan, I don't hold Walter Offutt in the same high regard as DJ Cooper. Are we ever going to see an all time great who begins and completes his college journey entirely at Ohio? To be honest, I don't want to get my hopes up and get excited for three more years of AJ Brown, a guy who has the potential to be one of the top 10 scorers in school history, who is not from the region and has a younger brother committed to the big school in his home state. [/QUOTE]I mean, I hear you. But I just don't get how one justifies restricting transfers given what you're saying. I mean, basically you're saying that AJ Brown might want to go play basketball with his brother. Is it somehow consistent with the NCAAs mission to keep that from happening? How does one justify it?
I think the sport loses something when that is gone. Isn't it cool that we have Gary Trent in our history (I'm making an exception for guys who leave for the pros early; Trent could have transferred almost anywhere after his freshman year in today's landscape)? Isn't it cool that Miami has Szczerbiak and Harper? Ball State has Bonzi? Weber State has Dame?
100% agree. The sport loses something. But I think I disagree with the premise. Would Trent have transferred if he wouldn't have had to sit out a year? If so, that sort of sucks. It basically means that players only stay at Ohio because of a contractual obligation.
Which is kind of the core issue here. The root of people's issues here are really about the "fan experience." And we're fans, so that makes sense. But the problem is that this is amateur athletics and the NCAA claims their mission is to educate first. Where does the fan experience fit into that mission, exactly? Certainly it's not a legally justifiable reason to restrict the freedom of an individual to study where they'd like.
Pro sports has a solution to this: employment. And that employment's structured with set duration contracts. Without that, I don't think the NCAA's going to have much of a leg to stand on if they try and restrict student movement. There aren't restrictions on a Chemistry Major's ability to transfer from one school to another, even if they're on scholarship. Hard to treat basketball players differently.
[QUOTE=shabamon]
Look at Grant Nelson who is leaving North Dakota State after three years for Alabama. If he stays at NDSU, he's a jersey in the rafters guy. In a year's time if he's drafted, Alabama gets all the credit and NDSU is the afterthought. I don't want Ohio to become the stepping stone or he afterthought.