It is equivalent and I’ve already explained why.
Sorry man, I don't really follow your explanation on this. You stated up-thread that: "Not removing games he’s played double-digit minutes to conclude your analysis is equivalent to looking at a hitters entire slash without breaking down how he faired against righties and lefties, then determining his overall value. Ike’s splits to date suggest he plays better when he plays more minutes."
But I don't see lefty/righty splits as remotely equivalent to minutes played. There's a reason guys don't get minutes and it's a meaningful data point that Cornish hasn't consistently broken into the rotation and earned the sort of minutes you're suggesting he needs to play to be successful.
All I'm doing is looking at all of the minutes he's played, and his rate stats during those minutes. I recognize that's not perfect, but it's not like I'm just making things up out of thin air.
You are grossly overvaluing the strength of MAC (or Mid-Major in general) basketball in comparison to P5 basketball. Again, if aIguy is cracking the rotation at any P5 school, he’s certainly not looking for opportunities at this level. On the flip side, Tanner Holden couldn’t replicate success on a below .500 OSU team. Ali’s numbers dipped on a sub .500 Butler team. Where are they now?
Jeff Boals is the MAC's highest paid coach. We should be a top 3 program in the MAC year in, year out, and we should be in the NCAA tournament every 4-5 years. Maryland and Louisville (in Wiz's case) are teams we should be competitive with. If a guy can't get any minutes at one of those schools, I don't think it's a strong indicator for him being a difference maker for us. Maybe you think the P5 is so good that the 3rd guy off the bench for a school like Maryland is a difference maker in the MAC. I suspect that's quite rare. Not impossible, but rare.
As for Ali Ali, he just stopped making threes. He shot terribly at Butler, and he's shooting terribly so far for Akron this year. I'm not so sure it's the level he's playing at. Just seems like the yips.
Some people are glass half full, some are glass half empty. Others just have the wrong glass. Be critical all you want, let me know when it’s ok to be critical of your takes. Here, you first.
I've been engaging in conversation with you about my take. It wasn't until you decided it was some irrational thing that could only be driven by an "axe to grind" with Cornish and that my take here means that "[Ike] totally sucks and so does this team" that I said "let me know when it's okay to be critical of that."
I don't think my take here is all that crazy. I'm suggesting that a guy who transferred in and is currently our 10th man -- and that a whole bunch of people here projected as our starting 4(here's the thread from when he committed:
https://bobcatattack.com/messageboard/topic.asp?FromPage=... ) -- has been a disappointing recruit.
Maybe he'll be better in the future. I hope so. But we're through the non-conference schedule at this point, and there's a lot to be critical of with this team and with Boals. Boals is in year 5 here, and there are very valid reasons to be concerned about the talent on the floor.
Oh, and P.S. Merry Christmas to you, too.
Last Edited: 12/26/2023 7:00:29 PM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame