Elton Alexander is a professional troll. He posts ridiculous statements he doesn't actually believe (.500 BG is the 5th best hoops team in Ohio) to create a buzz for his articles to generate more interest.
Would this article have been posted here if it was a realistic take on things? Maybe on this board if it involved Ohio or someone felt we got snubbed, but what about on other message boards or by other beat writers on twitter urging fans to read? Probably not. I am sure Xavier fans wouldn't have cared if they were #2 behind OSU. Or even #3. But not ranked while two teams they beat are ranked? Yes, that'll absolutely create a buzz. Extra views for the Plain Dealer and Elton!
Personally, I have no problem with this style of writing. Everyone needs to make a living. Views ultimately are the key to getting paid in his job. Elton is one of the best at getting views using this method. Truly a legend in this field.