Given the lack of health, you might be right. But, a healthy Dartis, Carter, and TK would in my opinion. Hall wasn't great, though versatile. Smith walked out on his team, and Ricardo, like much of this current team, was left with the "we'll never know" because of the injury.
And seriously, our "current bench"? Good God man, you realize they finished the game tonight with SEVEN healthy scholarship players, right? Remember when John had that in 2008-09, why 8-9 scholarship players? They weren't great either.
I will go ahead and contest everything in the response by OU_Country. The Sweet 16 year was not an "outlier". 49 wins and a MAC regular season championship suggest that our trajectory was on the up. I am not a JC apologist, so the meteoric drop in 14-15 was not all Saul, BUT it does show that this year is also not an outlier. The notorious 10 win 14-15 team had (1) NBA player, (1) G League player, an emotional/aggressive leader in Setty, and a Freshman in Taylor that was clearly going to be special. The team was not cohesive and our coach apparently could not foster an environment that lead to team health (from a mental perspective). That 10 win team makes this year's team look like the University of Rio Grande's JV based on talent and the one constant is Saul.
The statement regarding the current bench is a testimonial on the state of our current leadership. Saul recruited our bench. We have scholarships on that bench that are not given minutes in a 16 point blow-out at BG (!). I am no D-1 basketball coach, but I'd have to assume if you're on scholarship and you're not getting minutes in a game like last night, there might be a problem. The problem was created and should be owned by Saul. He's recruited D-3 talent and tried to squeeze it into our wonderful new Adidas duds. All the while accepting the #1 paycheck in the conference.
Finally, on to the 2011-12 talent. TJ might not have been great but there were games when he did take over and his athletic ability is a foreign concept to our current regime. Jon Smith did quit after the Cleveland loss, and I agree it was a stupid mistake for legacy's sake but his effort and presence has not been replaced since that ill fated decision. Finally regarding Ricardo, the injury happened long after we knew what we had. We had a shut down defender who might take a bad shot and could get to the rim. He was an athlete in an athletic system that recruited ATHLETES.
Lots of excuses and permissive attitudes flying around on this board. If we have a trophy ceremony for our 13 win or less season this year, I guess I will come out of loyalty but I won't agree.
Last Edited: 1/31/2018 8:06:37 AM by Townie1977